EU court adviser: services paid for with data aren't free.

An adviser to the EU's top court says handing over personal data, and agreeing to its commercial use, counts as payment under EU consumer law. If the judges agree, ad-funded services that require such data could no longer be advertised as "free".
Advocate General Laila Medina gave her opinion on 19 November in case C-643/25, brought by German consumer federation vzbv against Meta Platforms Ireland. The dispute goes back to February 2015, when Facebook's German registration page said "Facebook is and remains free". Two Berlin courts threw the claim out, holding that the EU ban on false "free" claims only covers payment in money. Germany's Federal Court of Justice then asked Luxembourg what "pay" means in point 20 of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive's blacklist.
Medina's answer is that it covers data and consent, unless the data are used only to run the service or to meet legal duties. She points to earlier case law accepting non-cash payment (PPC Land identifies it as the 2021 Peek & Cloppenburg ruling on advertorials) and to later EU laws, including the Digital Content Directive, that already treat data-for-service deals as an exchange. She rejected Meta's three counter-arguments: a narrow reading of the blacklist, the GDPR, and business freedom. In her view the GDPR governs how data is processed, not whether a "free" claim is accurate, so both rules apply side by side.
The opinion is not binding. The judges have only started deliberating and no judgment date is set, and the German court will then decide the case itself. According to PPC Land's reading of the full opinion Medina did not address Meta's paid ad-free subscription in the EU or say whether passively collected data, such as cookies, would count on their own. It also lands eight days after the Commission proposed, on 11 November, a Digital Fairness Act to replace the directive, which Parliament and the Council still have to agree.
For Gulf apps and brands that market to EU consumers, the word itself is the issue. If the Court follows Medina, any sign-up page, app store listing or ad that calls a service free while requiring users to hand over data for commercial use, beyond what running the service or legal duties need, would be banned in every member state, with no need to show that anyone was misled.
Why it matters
If the Court agrees, calling a service "free" in the EU while requiring users' data for commercial use would be banned outright, so data-funded services selling to Europeans should check their copy.
Related trends.

Google lets Target and Albertsons build grocery carts inside Search and Gemini
Google has started rolling out Connected Apps for Albertsons, Safeway, Shaw's and Target in Search and the Gemini app in the US, so its AI can build a grocery order and take it to checkout. Experian and H&R Block are coming to Search too.
Why it mattersGrocery product choice, the heart of retail media, can now start inside Google's AI answers, and Google hasn't said how products are ranked or whether brands can pay to appear.

Intuit agrees to sell Mailchimp to Bending Spoons for $3.68bn
Intuit has agreed to sell Mailchimp, the email marketing platform, to Bending Spoons at an enterprise value of about $3.68bn. Intuit bought Mailchimp for about $12bn in 2021, so the sale values it at less than a third of that price.
Why it mattersOne of the most widely used email marketing tools is changing hands at a steep discount, and its new owner says it deeply transforms the businesses it buys, monetisation included.

Microsoft opens ads in Bing AI Overviews in every market but China
Microsoft Advertising says ads can now appear next to AI Overviews in Bing search results in every market except China. There is no separate set-up: the placements run through existing campaigns, including Performance Max and AI Max.
Why it mattersAI answers are becoming ad inventory on a second big search engine, and existing Microsoft campaigns enter it automatically, Gulf markets included.